Appalachian Reckoning

As a twenty-year non-native resident of Appalachia who is about to go on hiatus outside the region, I’m happy to find a robust riposte to J.D. Vance’s unctuous Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis which unfairly takes to task some of the kindest, most welcoming people I have ever known. Mr. Vance wants you to know he followed the approved neo-lib wealth-acquiring path to its venture capitalist reward, and that the hillbilly people he grew up with can count filth, sloth and lack of couth as reasons they’ll never fill his wing-tips. It’s unkind and makes for a mean book. And personal. May I say, I didn’t much like it. Unfortunately, when it came out I’m afraid it ratified the coastal media’s self-esteem and they ate it up on the left, right and center.

The reply comes in the form of Appalachian Reckoning: A Region Responds to ‘Hillbilly Elegy,’ edited by Anthony Harkins and Meredith McCarroll. I’ve yet to read the book. I just became aware of it today, here. But I’m happy the West Virginia University Press has put it together, if for this quote alone, from Dwight B. Billings, a professor emeritus of sociology and Appalachian studies at the University of Kentucky: “It is one thing to write a personal memoir extolling the wisdom of one’s personal choices but quite something else — something extraordinarily audacious — to presume to write the ‘memoir’ of a culture.”

I’d like to think that in the three years since Hillbilly Elegy appeared we’ve begun to collectively reexamine some of the naked striving for unaccountable wealth that has marked the last thirty years.

Appalachia has its challenges. We’ll talk about that later. We’re about to take to the road again for a while and I’ll have valedictory remarks, but I’ll say for now that our home for the last twenty years is a beautiful place, full of wealth of the natural kind, and if my wife, dogs, cat, horses and I ran into a problem here on the farm, I promise I’d trust my neighbors the retired builder, the loggers or the guy who hustles a living with his Bobcat and gravel truck for their help way before a disdainful venture capitalist.

Here’s a little of our Appalachia for you:

6 thoughts on “Appalachian Reckoning

  1. Interestingly, I didn’t read the same things into Hillbilly Elegy that you did. Sure, it is a hard scramble life he portrays, and there are some tough consequences of lack of employment, but his love for the people and place he considers his shines through. My recollection as well is that despite his successes in a very different place he identifies most strongly with his roots. I didn’t think he was being disdainful so much as sad for what has been lost.


  2. At last, a thoughtful rebuke to Vance’s smug book. He is clearly disdainful of his fellow Appalachian citizens and does not humbly recognize how very rare the opportunities are that have fallen his way. Yes he took advantage of his luck but millions of others will never have a similar chance.


  3. An interesting and refreshing read! Thank you! I recently finished reading J.D. Vance’s book, “Hillbilly Elegy” and I have to say I felt a bit put off by some of it. Although I can relate to a lot of it, I feel it portrayed us from a very narrow-minded viewpoint and I was nothing short of offended by the suggestion that we are not successful financially due to what he might as well have called laziness. I will definitely be reading this “Appalachian Reckoning”.


  4. Pingback: On the Road: Leaving Home | 3 Quarks Daily

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s